East Village, Manhattan · bar
Tiki kitsch dialed up to eleven. Otto’s is that classic place where you can sip a flaming drink from a ceramic skull while a ska band thrashes in the back. Neon palm trees, bamboo-covered walls, and a cocktail menu that doesn’t hold back on the rum. You’ll leave wondering if that was just another night out or a fever dream fueled by mai tais and surf rock.
Rum cocktail with pineapple, orange, coconut, nutmeg
Traditional mai tai with orgeat and rum
Strong as hell. 151-proof rum, falernum, grenadine, and lime