mon, 8:00 PM - 11:00 PM · Hartley's, Bed-Stuy + Clinton Hill, New York City
Live traditional Irish trad session with Matt Stapleton & guests every Monday at 8pm. Named best pub in NYC by Grub Street — cozy Clinton Hill shebeen with pints of Guinness and house-baked Irish soda bread. No cover.
A candlelit room that actually earns the word “cozy”, the kind of place built around a proper pint and people who plan to stay a while. The Guinness gets obsessive attention, the Irish soda bread is baked in-house, and the food leans Irish comfort without overplaying it. Stew, sausages, grilled cheese with Ballymaloe relish.
Steamed mussels in Guinness broth with smoky bacon — a true pub staple
House-spiced beef, Irish cheddar & grilled onion on fresh-baked soda bread
Grass-fed beef & roasted root veg in Guinness, served with soda bread