Papa Do Preach: A Secret Variety Show

About Papa Do Preach: A Secret Variety Show

Monthly variety show at The Hidden Jewel Box Theater featuring comedians Maya Deshmukh, Prakash Puru, and Eric Feurer alongside performer Cornelius Loy, hosted by Katie Hartman in character.

At The Hidden Jewel Box

Tucked inside the Pershing Square Signature Center, this 99-seat stunner feels like theater’s best-kept secret. It’s intimate in the “you can hear the actor breathe” way, which makes every monologue feel mildly confrontational in the best way.

More about The Hidden Jewel Box

What to order at The Hidden Jewel Box

• Tequila Paper Plane

  $18

  Tequila with amaro nonino and aperol balanced by fresh lime.

• Green Tea Martini

  $18

  Vodka stirred with green tea and St Germain elderflower liqueur.

• Pistachio Espresso Martini

  $18

  Vodka shaken with chocolate liqueur and pistachio syrup over coffee.

Also at The Hidden Jewel Box

Details

• When: Wednesday, October 21, 2026, 11:30 PM - 2:30 AM
• Venue: The Hidden Jewel Box
• Address: 480 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036
• Neighborhood: Midtown

Discover more in New York City

• More in Midtown
• Best of New York City
• Happy hours in New York City
• Browse all events